top of page
Search

What Is Subrogation in Florida? How Insurers Get Paid Back

Writer: Daniel Reinfeld
Daniel Reinfeld
Oct 28
7 min read

Written and reviewed by Daniel B. Reinfeld, Esq. | Last updated October 28, 2026


Subrogation is the legal right of an insurance company that has paid for your loss to recover that money from the person who caused it. When someone else's negligence injures you or damages your property and your own insurer pays, the insurer steps into your shoes and pursues the at-fault party, or claims a share of your settlement, to get repaid. In a Florida injury case, subrogation and reimbursement claims can take a large bite out of what you actually take home, which is why they must be dealt with before a settlement is finalized, not after.

How Does Subrogation Work in Florida?

Subrogation starts with a simple idea: the party who caused the loss should ultimately pay for it, not the insurer who covered it in the meantime.

Here is the usual sequence. You are hurt or your property is damaged by someone else's negligence. Your insurer pays your claim, whether that is collision coverage for your car, health insurance for your medical bills, or medical payments coverage. The insurer then has a right to recover what it paid. It can do that in two ways: by pursuing the at-fault party directly (subrogation in the strict sense), or by asserting a claim against the money you recover from the at-fault party (reimbursement).

Because the insurer takes your place, it generally has no better rights than you had. If you could not have recovered from the at-fault party, neither can your insurer. If a jury would have found you partly at fault under section 768.81, the insurer's recovery is reduced the same way.

Subrogation rights come from two sources. Some arise from your insurance contract, which almost always contains a subrogation or reimbursement clause. Others arise from equity, the court-made doctrine that prevents the wrongdoer from escaping responsibility because the victim was insured.

Common Types of Subrogation Claims in Florida Injury Cases

Auto collision coverage. If your insurer pays to repair your car under collision coverage, it will pursue the at-fault driver's liability insurer. Insurers often resolve these claims between themselves through inter-company arbitration. If you paid a deductible, your insurer should seek that back too, and you should ask to be included in any recovery.

Health insurance. After a crash or fall, your health plan pays your hospital and doctors. When you settle with the at-fault party, the plan may assert a right to be repaid from the settlement. How strong that claim is depends heavily on what kind of plan you have, which is covered below.

Medicare and Medicaid. Government payers have statutory recovery rights that private insurers do not. Medicare is a secondary payer under federal law, 42 U.S.C. § 1395y(b)(2), and can demand repayment of conditional payments it made for accident-related care. Florida Medicaid's recovery right is set by section 409.910, Florida Statutes, which includes a statutory formula for how much the state may recover from a settlement. The U.S. Supreme Court held in Gallardo v. Marstiller, 596 U.S. 420 (2022), that a state Medicaid program may reach the portion of a settlement allocated to future medical care as well as past care.

Workers' compensation. If you are hurt on the job by a third party, such as a negligent driver or equipment manufacturer, the workers' compensation carrier that pays your benefits has a lien on your third-party recovery under section 440.39. The Florida Supreme Court addressed how that lien is reduced for attorney's fees and costs in Manfredo v. Employers Casualty Insurance Co., 560 So. 2d 1162 (Fla. 1990).

Personal injury protection (PIP). PIP is different. Under section 627.736(3), an injured person has no right to recover from the at-fault party damages for which PIP benefits have been paid or are payable, so a PIP insurer generally does not claim a share of your liability settlement. A narrow statutory reimbursement right exists against the owner or insurer of a commercial motor vehicle under section 627.7405.

What Is the Made-Whole Doctrine?

The made-whole doctrine is the most important protection many Florida injury victims have. It says that when your damages are greater than what you recover, your insurer should not be repaid until you have been fully compensated.

The Florida Supreme Court recognized this principle in Florida Physicians Insurance Reciprocal v. Stanley, 452 So. 2d 514 (Fla. 1984), holding that an insured must be made whole before an insurer can enforce its subrogation right, unless the contract clearly provides otherwise. In practice, this matters most when the at-fault driver has only minimum insurance limits, or when a serious injury is worth far more than the available coverage.

The made-whole doctrine is a default rule. Insurers write contracts that try to override it, and some plans are governed by federal law that changes the analysis completely.

Does the Type of Health Plan Matter?

Yes, enormously. This is the single most overlooked fact in subrogation disputes.

If your health insurance is fully insured, meaning an insurance company issued the policy and bears the risk, Florida law and the made-whole doctrine generally apply. If your coverage is a self-funded employer plan governed by ERISA, federal law can preempt Florida law, and the plan's written terms control. In US Airways, Inc. v. McCutchen, 569 U.S. 88 (2013), the U.S. Supreme Court held that an ERISA plan's terms govern reimbursement claims, and equitable defenses like the common-fund rule apply only when the plan is silent. Federal employee plans and Medicare Advantage plans each have their own rules too.

Many people do not know whether their employer plan is fully insured or self-funded, and the insurance card does not always say. Finding out, and getting the actual plan document, is one of the first things to do.

How Subrogation Affects Your Florida Settlement

Florida's collateral source statute, section 768.76, reduces a damages award by amounts you received from collateral sources such as health insurance. But it does not reduce the award for collateral sources that hold a right of subrogation or reimbursement. When a lien exists, the balance is handled through the lien instead.

The practical effect is that your settlement is divided in a particular order. The gross settlement comes in. Attorney's fees and case costs come out. Medical providers or the insurer's lien claims are addressed. What remains is yours. Subrogation claims therefore come straight out of what you would otherwise receive.

Liens are often negotiable. Insurers frequently reduce their claims, especially when the recovery is limited, when the lien includes charges unrelated to the accident, or when the insurer shares in the cost of procuring the recovery. Every lien should be requested in writing, itemized, and checked line by line against the accident.

What Happens If You Ignore a Subrogation Claim?

Ignoring a lien does not make it disappear. A health insurer or government payer can pursue you directly, withhold future benefits, or pursue the attorney or others who handled the funds. Medicare can seek repayment plus, in some situations, double damages under federal law. A settlement that distributes funds without resolving the liens can leave the injured person owing money after the case is closed.

Before any settlement check is distributed, every potential lien should be identified and resolved. That includes health insurance, Medicare, Medicaid, workers' compensation, hospital claims, and med-pay.

How Long Does an Insurer Have to Bring a Subrogation Claim?

A subrogated insurer generally has the same time limit you had on the underlying claim. For negligence claims that accrued on or after March 24, 2023, that is two years under section 95.11(5)(a). A contractual reimbursement claim against you is governed by the limitations period for contract claims, which is generally longer. Do not assume a lien has expired because two years have passed.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is subrogation in simple terms? It is an insurer's right to recover from the person who caused your loss the money the insurer paid you or on your behalf.

Can my health insurance take money from my Florida settlement? Often yes. It depends on your policy language, whether the plan is fully insured or self-funded under ERISA, and whether you have been made whole.

What is the difference between subrogation and reimbursement? Subrogation is the insurer's right to step into your shoes and pursue the at-fault party. Reimbursement is the insurer's right to be repaid from the money you recover.

Does PIP have a right of subrogation? Generally not against the at-fault driver. Section 627.736(3) bars you from recovering PIP-paid damages from the at-fault party, and the PIP reimbursement right in section 627.7405 is limited to commercial motor vehicles.

Can a lien be reduced? Often. Reductions depend on the type of lien, the amount of the recovery, the contract language, and the governing law. Government and ERISA claims follow their own rules.

Do I still owe my deductible if my insurer pursues subrogation? If your insurer recovers, it should reimburse your deductible, usually proportionally. Ask your adjuster whether your deductible is included.

Should I tell my lawyer about every insurer that paid anything? Yes. A missed lien becomes your problem after the settlement is disbursed.

Resolving Liens Takes Careful Preparation

A settlement is not the finish line. What you keep depends on how every insurer and government payer that paid a bill gets repaid, and those claims have deadlines, formulas, and negotiating room that most people never see.

Call Today. Discuss Directly With Dan.

When you call Daniel B Reinfeld, PA, you speak directly with Dan, not a call center. He has practiced law for more than 25 years, including years as an insurance defense attorney, so he knows how insurers value, assert, and compromise their reimbursement claims. Consultations are free, and there is no fee unless we recover for you. Dan meets by phone, by Zoom, at the hospital, or at your home, and evening and weekend appointments are available. Call (954) 923-6110 or email dan@reinfeldlaw.com.



Daniel B Reinfeld, PA, 2450 Hollywood Boulevard, Suite 706, Hollywood, FL 33020. Serving Broward, Miami-Dade, Monroe, and Palm Beach Counties.

This article is general information, not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change, and every case depends on its own facts. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

© 2026 Daniel B Reinfeld, PA.

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page